From Plato to Tolstoi art has been accused of exciting our emotions and thus of disturbing the order and harmony of our moral life. “Poetical imagination, according to Plato, waters our experience of lust and anger, of desire and pain, and makes them grow when they ought to starve with drought.” Tolstoi sees in art a source of infection. “Not only in infection,” he says, “a sign of art, but the degree of infectiousness is also the sole measure of excellence in art.” But the flaw in this theory is obvious. Tolstoi suppresses a fundamental moment of art, the moment of form. The aesthetic experience - the experience of contemplation - is a different state of mind from the coolness of our theoretical and the sobriety of our moral judgment. It is filled with the liveliest energies of passion, but passion itself is here transformed both in its nature and in its meaning. Wordsworth defines poetry as “emotion recollected in tranquility.” But the tranquility we feel in great poetry is not that of recollection. The emotions aroused by the poet do not belong to a remote past. They are “here” - alive and immediate. We are aware of their full strength, but this strength tends in a new direction. It is rather seen than immediately felt. Our passions are no longer dark and impenetrable powers; they become, as it were, transparent. Shakespeare never gives us an aesthetic theory. He does not speculate about the nature of art. Yet in the only passage in which he speaks of the character and functions of dramatic art the whole stress is laid upon this point. “The purpose of playing,” as Hamlet explains, “both at the first and now, was and is, to hold, as, twere, the mirror up to nature; to show virtue her own feature, scorn her own image, and the very age and body of the time, his form and pressure.” But the image of the passion is not the passion itself. The poet who represents a passion does not infect us with this passion. At a Shakespeare play we are not infected with the ambition of Macbeth, with the cruelty of Richard III or with the jealously of Othello. We are not at the mercy of these emotions; we look through them; we seem to penetrate into their very nature and essence. In this respect Shakespeare’s theory of dramatic art, if he had such a theory, is in complete agreement with the conception of the fine arts of the great painters and sculptors.
CSS 2009 Solved Precis
1 November 2025
|
310
3 Min. Read
0 Comments
Share Via
CSS 2009 Solved Precis is a valuable model passage designed to help CSS aspirants develop clarity, conciseness, and coherence in precis writing. This past paper solution highlights how to transform a lengthy and detailed paragraph into a well-structured precis while retaining the author’s original tone and message. It helps learners understand the art of identifying key ideas, removing redundancy, and presenting the core thought with accuracy, skills that are vital for scoring well in the CSS English (Précis & Composition) paper.
Ideal for both beginners and advanced aspirants, this CSS Solved Precis from the CSS 2009 paper is a practical example of effective precision and logical structuring. It enables students to refine their analytical reading and writing abilities, which are crucial for the essay and comprehension sections as well. Through consistent practice with such a model precis, aspirants gain confidence in making proficient precis solutions.
Prepared and explained by Sir Syed Kazim Ali, Pakistan’s most renowned English mentor, this solved precis is a step-by-step guide that empowers aspirants to grasp the techniques of compression, coherence, and expression, making this resource indispensable for those preparing for CSS, PMS, and other competitive exams in Pakistan.
CSS 2009 Solved Precis
Join Sir Syed Kazim Ali’s Extensive CSS/PMS English Course
Master the art of Essay and Precis writing with Pakistan’s most trusted English mentor. Strengthen grammar, expand vocabulary, and learn examiner-tested strategies through real practice and expert guidance. Limited seats—enroll today!
Precis Solution
Important Vocabulary
- Contemplation (noun): The action of looking thoughtfully at something for a long time; deep reflective thought
- Contextual Explanation: The aesthetic experience is defined as the experience of contemplation, meaning deep, thoughtful observation.
- Sobriety (noun): The state of being sober (not drunk); in this context, seriousness and moderation
- Contextual Explanation: The aesthetic experience is distinguished from the sobriety of our moral judgment, referring to its serious, moderated nature.
- Tranquility (noun): The state of being calm
- Contextual Explanation: Wordsworth defines poetry as emotion recollected in tranquility, or calmness.
- Impenetrable (adjective): Impossible to pass through or enter; impossible to understand
- Contextual Explanation: Our passions are no longer dark and impenetrable powers; they become transparent, meaning they are no longer impossible to understand.
- Speculate (verb): To form a theory or conjecture about a subject without firm evidence
- Contextual Explanation: Shakespeare does not speculate about the nature of art, meaning he does not form theories about it.
Important Ideas of the Passage
The passage analyzes how individuals, from ancient thinkers like Plato to moralists like Tolstoi, accused art of corrupting human emotions and disturbing their moral order. It explains that people misjudged art because they ignored its form, which transforms their passions into clarity and understanding. Thus, through the insights of Wordsworth and Shakespeare, individuals are shown that art does not infect their moral sense but refines their feelings, enabling them to perceive and understand human emotions more deeply. Moreover, the aim is to show people that although they may fear art for its emotional power, it actually purifies their passions through form. So, by engaging with art aesthetically, individuals learn to feel deeply yet think clearly; they understand human emotion instead of being overwhelmed by it, maintaining their moral balance through insight rather than suppression.
Main Idea of the Passage
- People who condemn art for exciting their emotions and disturbing their moral life fail to see that through form, art transforms their passions into vision and understanding, enabling them to feel yet remain morally clear.
Supporting Ideas Helping the Main Idea
- People from Plato to Tolstoi believed that art excites human emotions, such as lust, anger, desire, and pain, and that this emotional stimulation could disturb their moral balance.
- These individuals overlooked that art's true power lies in its form, which transforms how they experience passion, turning raw emotion into clarity and understanding.
- When people engage with art aesthetically, they feel the liveliness of passion, yet their experience of it is refined and controlled, allowing them to comprehend emotion without being overwhelmed.
- Wordsworth helped individuals realize that emotion recollected in tranquility enables them to retain the intensity of their feelings while reflecting on their meaning.
- Shakespeare's dramatic art allows audiences to observe human passions mirrored on stage, enabling them to recognize ambition, cruelty, or jealousy without being infected by these emotions and preserving their moral and intellectual balance.
Confused About Main and Supporting Ideas?
Kindly make sure to revise all five lectures on Precis Writing that I have already delivered. In these sessions, we discussed in detail:
- What a precis is and its purpose.
- What the main idea means and how to extract it effectively.
- What supporting ideas are and how to identify them.
- How to coordinate the main and supporting ideas while writing a concise, coherent precis.
Additionally, go through the 20 examples I shared in the WhatsApp groups. These examples highlight the Dos and Don’ts of Precis Writing, and revising them will help you avoid common mistakes and refine your technique.
Precis
Precis 1
From Plato to Tolstoi, people believed that art excites human emotions, such as lust, anger, desire, and pain, potentially disturbing their moral judgment. Specifically, they considered passion aroused by art as dangerous and morally disruptive. However, people experience art differently as its form transforms people's passion into understanding rather than their raw emotion. In fact, when individuals engage aesthetically, they feel strong emotions while maintaining reflection and control. For example, Wordsworth showed that people can recollect emotion in peace, preserving the intensity while gaining insight. Similarly, Shakespeare's plays allow audiences to observe ambition, cruelty, and jealousy mirrored in characters, enabling people to understand human passions without being infected by them. Therefore, art refines emotions, heightens awareness, and preserves moral and intellectual balance, allowing people to experience powerful feelings while maintaining ethical judgment and comprehension of their essence.
- Original Words in the Passage: 423
- Precis Word Count: 137
- Title: Art and Human Emotion: From Passion to Reflection
Precis 2
People from Plato to Tolstoi feared that art excites their lust, anger, desire, and pain, which might disturb their moral and ethical judgment. Particularly, they thought passion aroused by art is dangerous. However, people experience art through its form, which transforms their raw emotion into a clear understanding. As a result, individuals feel emotions while pondering on them, helping them gain insight without being overwhelmed. For example, Wordsworth explained that contemplation enables people to retain their passion while thinking. Similarly, Shakespeare’s plays display emotions: ambition, cruelty, and jealousy, enabling audiences to understand human passions without being consumed by them. Therefore, art refines human emotions, sharpens their awareness, and maintains their moral balance, letting them feel deeply while reflecting ethically.
- Original Words in the Passage: 423
- Precis Word Count: 119
- Title: The Transformative Power of Art on Human Passions
Precis 3
People from Plato to Tolstoi believed art dangerously stirs human passions like lust, anger, and desire, threatening their moral judgment. Yet art's form transforms human emotion, allowing them to feel and consider simultaneously. To illustrate, Wordsworth noted that recollected emotion enables people to retain intensity with calm understanding. Similarly, Shakespeare's plays display humans' ambition, cruelty, and jealousy, letting audiences observe passions without being infected. Therefore, art refines and balances the mind, allowing people to experience intense emotions while preserving their insight and ethical judgment.
- Original Words in the Passage: 423
- Precis Word Count: 84
- Title: Art Refines Emotion and Preserves Moral Judgment
Precis 4
Individuals from Plato to Tolstoi believed that art dangerously ignites their passions like lust and anger, threatening their moral judgment. However, art's form allows them to feel and reflect collectively. For instance, Wordsworth noted that recollected emotion maintains intensity while Shakespeare's plays enable them to observe ambition and cruelty without being harmed, thus refining their mind and preserving their insight and ethical judgment.
- Original Words in the Passage: 423
- Precis Word Count: 63
- Title: Art Shapes Human Emotion and Ethical Understanding
Want to Know Who Sir Syed Kazim Ali Is?
Sir Syed Kazim Ali is Pakistan’s top English mentor for CSS & PMS, renowned for producing qualifiers through unmatched guidance in essay, precis, and communication. Discover how he turns serious aspirants into high-scoring, confident candidates.
1st Update: October 31, 2025
Comments
From This Category
CSS 2017 Solved Precis
Discover the CSS 2017 solved precis featuring multiple versions, essential ideas, and key vocabulary to improve your precis writing skills and boost exam readiness.
15 July 2025
|
366
Syed Kazim Ali
CSS 2010 Solved Precis
CSS 2010 Solved Precis by Sir Syed Kazim Ali on PrecisWritingLet helps aspirants ace precision, coherence, and linguistic control for the CSS English Precis.
30 October 2025
|
318
Syed Kazim Ali
Latest
CSS 2010 Solved Precis
CSS 2010 Solved Precis by Sir Syed Kazim Ali on PrecisWritingLet helps aspirants ace precision, coherence, and linguistic control for the CSS English Precis.
30 October 2025
|
318
Syed Kazim Ali
R. Dhillon Solved Precis Passage Seven
Practice advanced precis writing with R. Dhillon Solved Precis Passage Seven sourced from Precis Writing by R. Dhillon and solved by Sir Syed Kazim Ali.
3 November 2025
|
308
Syed Kazim Ali